Download Archaeology and Ancient History: Breaking Down the by Eberhard W. Sauer PDF

By Eberhard W. Sauer

A few classicists nonetheless care for the traditional global as though archaeological proof is of little relevance to their paintings. this may suggest that territories or topics for which there's little textual proof might be marginalised or no longer studied in any respect. equally, many historic archaeologists, disillusioned with their ancillary function, assert that fabric proof for the traditional international can and may be studied independently. although efforts are being made - in a few quarters a minimum of - to erode those disciplinary barriers, in others they've got turn into more and more fossilized, and rifts inside of topics are resulting in ever extra remoted sub disciplines. whereas representatives of every assorted specialism may perhaps think they've got came upon the trail to old fact, the true fact is that the straitjackets of disciplinary barriers - no matter if generations previous or fashionably novel - are stifling innovation, creativity, and the opportunity of illuminating the prior with all of the wisdom at our disposal. This choice of items from overseas participants explores the separation of the learn of the human previous into historical past and archaeology, hard its validity and asking how we will movement to a holistic procedure. whereas the focal point is at the old international, fairly Greece and Rome, the teachings that emerge are major for the examine of anyplace and time.

Show description

Read or Download Archaeology and Ancient History: Breaking Down the Boundaries PDF

Best ancient books

The Romans: Builders of an Empire (Reece, Katherine E., Ancient Civilizations)

Find out how the traditional Roman civilization started, constructed, flourished and died out. examine alternate, arts, schooling, politics and spiritual ideals. contains photos, illustrations, sidebars timeline, thesaurus, index, studying checklist and internet sites.

Mithridates VI and the Pontic Kingdom (Black Sea Studies)

Mithridates VI Eupator, the final king of Pontos, was once unquestionably the most favourite figures within the overdue Hellenistic interval. all through his lengthy reign (120-63 BC), the political and cultural panorama of Asia Minor and the Black Sea quarter was once reshaped alongside new traces. The authors current new archaeological examine and new interpretations of varied elements of Pontic society and its contacts with the Greek global and its japanese neighbours and examine the historical past for the growth of the Pontic state that at last resulted in the war of words with Rome.

Houses and Households: A Comparative Study

The writer offers a wide comparative database derived from ethnographic and architectural learn in Southeast Asia, Egypt, Mesoamerica, and different parts; proposes new methodologies for comparative analyses of homes; and severely examines present methodologies, theories, and knowledge. His paintings expands on and systematizes comparative and cross-cultural ways to the research of families and their environments to supply an organization origin for this rising line of analysis.

Extra info for Archaeology and Ancient History: Breaking Down the Boundaries

Example text

8 per cent in terms of its length), is the domain solely of archaeologists. 2 per cent of human history (and with far less for most parts of the world) and excludes the origins of the human species, agriculture, permanent settlements and urbanism. Even within the last five millennia only archaeologists have the competence to deal comprehensively with the history of any culture for which there is no documentary evidence. Once, however, the first texts give a partial insight into a culture, the term ‘historian’ is claimed by those who attempt a historical interpretation of these documents.

If we do not present the whole mosaic, if we split it up into individual tesserae, we may ourselves forget the sense of our work, and we will not be able to convey it to anybody else. The emancipation of archaeology? While some archaeologists (and many historians) are content with archaeology playing the role of the proverbial ‘handmaiden of history’, others strive towards equality. Austin (1990: 10) laments that school textbooks ‘are based almost solely on documentary evidence, although they may incidentally include pictures of material things such as castles or coins’.

Carver 2002). Yet it appears that he almost comes to the opposite conclusions when criticizing demands that archaeology should recover ancient texts, be it in Mesopotamia, the Mediterranean, China, Vindolanda in Roman Britain or on Maya sites in central America: Subservience to the demands of history is even more evident in those cases where the practice of archaeology is explicitly directed at the recovery of ancient written material. Here archaeology ceases to be a discipline in its own right and serves merely as a producer of texts to be consumed by historians and philologists.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.17 of 5 – based on 38 votes